“When the debate is lost, slander becomes the tool of the loser’ (Socrates) – What did really happen in Debre Markos?

Source: https://www.satenaw.com/when-the-debate-is-lost-slander-becomes-the-tool-of-the-loser-socrates-what-did-really-happen-in-debre-markos/

The remarks Ato Gedu made on the incident in Debre Markos were thoughtful and measured. He should be applauded. He knows well all these various incidents flaring up in all part of the country have their roots in the ‘ethnic’ based politics instituted and practiced by his own party, namely EPRDF.

Yet, others are criticizing his remarks and labeled him as a supporter of TPLF. Others, while applauding Ato Gedu, still hold responsible Ato Bereket and TPLF. And, still others list names of the organization they say are from Tigre.

We want to comment on a few of these opinions.

Ato Seretse: ‘እውንም እንደተባለው ደብረ ማርቆስ ላይ የተቃጠለው የበረከት ሥምዖን መኪና ከሆነ  ሕዝብ ለወሰደው እርምጃ አድናቆቴ ትልቅ ነው፡፡’

This is nothing more than encouraging lawlessness and mob justice.

እንደተባለውም በረከት ደብረ ማርቆስ ላይ ከታየ ምን ሊሰራ፡፡

For one, no one has proof Ato Bereket was in Debre Markos, and for another, Ato Bereket has every right to be in Debre Markos. Moreover, this is counter-productive to the love and ‘ethiopiawinet’ that is being preached.  Are we now saying there are places Ato Bereket and the likes of him are allowed to go and not go? This we believe is total nonsense and should simply be dismissed.

Ato Girma ‘ሕወሃት በአማራ ክልል ውስጥ ጉዳት ለማድረስ የቻለው በብአዴኖች በኩል መሆኑን ለማሳየት ስለፈለጉ ይመስለኛል አቶ ገዱ “እኛ” ያሉት.” It is an interesting take on the part of Ato Girma; a cleaver twist.  Ato Girma wants us to believe this was what Ato Gedu really and actually meant i.e. Yes, it was the work of “ሕወሃት”.

No, Ato Gedu did not say that. We don’t need to read anything into it. It is clear as mud what Ato Gedu said.

Beyond that, Ato Gedu even commended the sacrifices the former leaders of the organization had made and rightly so. Let us name one political party or organization in the world that can rightly claim it never did anything wrong. Obviously, mistakes and lots of them have been made by EPRDF and its member organizations.

“አዎን ሕወሃት እጁ አለበት፤…አቶ በረከት በሕወሃት ገንዘብ ተመድቦለት በአማራ ክልል እየዞረ ለዉጡን ለመቀልበስ እየሰራ ነው…እኛ ግን ሌባውን ለምን ሌባ አላሉም እንቆጣለን።

What evidence does Ato Girma have to substantiate his claim? In today’s parlance this will pass as ‘fake news’. Ato Gedu did not want to say “ሌባ” because he knows better and that there is no merit to it.

Ato Achamyeleh, on the other hand, ranted about the organization’s composition and he listed members he said are from Tigre. Does he not know there are thousands of people born and raised in Gondar, Wolleo etc and lived there for generations who can trace their lineage to Tigre? What is wrong with that really? They are a bon fide Amhara just like Ato Achamyeleh.

Experience has taught us that not being civil almost always derails any rational exchanges. It can easily result in polarizing both sides more, and can have real negative consequences for all.

Insults are the last resort of insecure people with a crumbling position trying to appear confident. As one wise person puts it, “When you resort to name calling, you have lost the argument”.

Zekarias Ezra


Share this post

One thought on ““When the debate is lost, slander becomes the tool of the loser’ (Socrates) – What did really happen in Debre Markos?

  1. I agree completely that Gedu’s speech was measured and reflective of events happened
    Destroying people’s property is hooliganism by any measure. Ato Bereket has the right to move freely and any Tigre has the right to work and live in Amara land as you said. But here is one thing. Amaras will not welcome you if you side with the enemy., TPLF. Think of the thousands of Amaras arrested by TPLF and suffered and humulated. That sets anger and resentment. There is also one contribution Gedu’s party is responsible for the growing anger. He should have cleansed his party that work for TPLF. Lemma Megersa did long time ago and Gedu did not learn his lesson. I agree there is no mob justice for Bereket alone.


Post Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.